dú fàn
毒贩
pàn jué
判决
bèi hòu
背后
de
guó jì
国际
yú lùn
舆论
International Public Opinion Behind Drug Traffickers' Sentences
chén zhì gāo陈智高wáng míng yuè王明月tàn tǎo探讨zhōngjiāsǐ xíng死刑zhēng yì争议bèi hòu背后dewén huà文化fǎ lǜ法律guān niàn观念chā yì差异

陈智高 and 王明月 discuss the cultural and legal differences behind the death penalty controversy between China and Canada.

王明月
shī fù师父nínkàn dào看到zuì jìn最近dexīn wén新闻lemazhōng guó中国yī fǎ依法duìmíngjiā ná dà jí加拿大籍dú fàn毒贩zhí xíng执行lesǐ xíng死刑jiā fāng加方qiáng liè强烈kàng yì抗议dànhěnduōwài guó外国wǎng mín网民quèzhī chí支持zhōng fāng中方zuò fǎ做法shèn zhì甚至liányī xiē一些jiā ná dà加拿大rénbiǎo shì表示lǐ jiě理解

Master, have you seen the recent news? China lawfully executed four Canadian drug traffickers. Canada strongly protested, but many foreign netizens supported China's actions, and even some Canadians expressed understanding.

陈智高
kàn dào看到lezhèqí shí其实fǎn yìng反映chūfǎ lǜ法律bèi hòu背后dewén huà文化chā yì差异xī fāng西方guó jiā国家pǔ biàn普遍fǎn duì反对sǐ xíng死刑érzhōng guó中国shìdú pǐn毒品fàn zuì犯罪wèiyán zhòng严重wēi xié威胁shè huì社会wěn dìng稳定dexíng wéi行为yī fǎ依法yán chéng严惩bù zú wéi qí不足为奇

Yes, I saw it. This actually reflects the cultural differences behind legal systems. Western countries generally oppose the death penalty, while China views drug crimes as a serious threat to social stability, so severe punishment is not surprising.

王明月
shìdezhù yì注意dàoyǒuwǎng yǒu网友píng lùn评论shuōjiā ná dà加拿大méi tǐ媒体biāo tí标题yīngwèimíngdú fàn毒贩érbú shì不是míngjiā ná dà加拿大rénzhèhuàjiǎn zhí简直yī zhēn jiàn xiě一针见血

Right. I noticed one comment saying that Canadian media headlines should read 'Four Drug Traffickers' instead of 'Four Canadians.' That comment was spot-on.

陈智高
zhèshuō míng说明gōng zhòng公众duìshēn fèn身份xíng wéi行为zhī jiān之间deqū fēn区分yuè lái yuè越来越qīng xī清晰yí gè一个guó jiā国家defǎ lǜ法律bù néng不能yīn wèi因为fàn zuì zhě犯罪者deguó jí国籍érdòng yáo动摇fǒu zé否则fǎ zhì法治cúnrù xiāng suí sú入乡随俗zàifǎ lǜ法律céng miàn层面yīngshìguóshǒu fǎ守法

This shows that the public is becoming more aware of the distinction between 'identity' and 'actions.' A country's law cannot be swayed by the criminal's nationality; otherwise, what remains of the rule of law? 'When in Rome, do as the Romans do' should also mean 'When in a country, abide by its laws.'

王明月
dànshī fù师父jiā ná dà加拿大wèi shén me为什么hái shì还是rú cǐ如此qiáng liè强烈fǎn yìng反应shìchū yú出于rén dào zhǔ yì人道主义lì chǎng立场hái shì还是zhèng zhì政治kǎo liáng考量

But Master, why is Canada still reacting so strongly? Is it due to humanitarian concerns or political considerations?

陈智高
liǎng zhě两者dōuyǒujiā ná dà加拿大zǎo yǐ早已fèi chú废除sǐ xíng死刑tā men他们cóngjià zhí guān价值观chū fā出发zì rán自然nán yǐ难以jiē shòu接受dànzhèng zhì政治shàngruòkàng yì抗议yú lùn舆论huìpī píng批评zhèng fǔ政府zuò wéi作为rán ér然而zhè zhǒng这种kàng yì抗议kě néng可能shì dé qí fǎn适得其反bèishì wèi视为gān shè干涉guónèi zhèng内政

Both. Canada abolished the death penalty long ago, so from their value perspective, they find it hard to accept. Politically, if they don't protest, public opinion might criticize the government as 'doing nothing.' However, such protests could backfire and be seen as interference in another country's internal affairs.

王明月
háikàn dào看到wèiměi guó美国wǎng mín网民depíng lùn评论shuōjiā ná dà加拿大céngfǒu rèn否认dú fàn毒贩zàiměihuó dòng活动xiàn zài现在shì shí事实bǎizàiyǎn qián眼前dǎ liǎn打脸qīngzhè xiē这些píng lùn评论dàoràngjué de觉得yú lùn舆论guān fāng官方gèngyǒudòng chá lì洞察力

I also saw a comment from an American netizen saying Canada once denied the drug traffickers were active in the US, but now the evidence is clear — a real slap in the face. It makes me think that public opinion sometimes has sharper insights than official statements.

陈智高
qún zhòng群众deyǎn jīng眼睛què shí确实xuě liàng雪亮zhōng guó中国gǔ yǔ古语shuōāguìbù lùn不论shēn fèn身份dì wèi地位zhǐ yào只要wéi fǎ违法jiùgāiyī fǎ依法chéng zhì惩治jīn tiān今天miàn duì面对quán qiú huà全球化xiàdekuà guó跨国fàn zuì犯罪guó jiā国家zhī jiān之间gèngyīngzūn zhòng尊重bǐ cǐ彼此desī fǎ司法zhǔ quán主权

The public eye is indeed keen. As the Chinese saying goes, 'The law does not bend to the powerful.' Regardless of status or nationality, those who break the law should be punished accordingly. In today's globalized world, countries should respect each other's judicial sovereignty in dealing with transnational crimes.

王明月
shī fù师父zhèjiànshìràngxiǎng qǐ想起nínchángshuōdefǎ lǜ法律shìwén huà文化dejìng zi镜子bù tóng不同guó jiā国家rú hé如何kàn dài看待chéng fá惩罚fǎn yìng反映legè zì各自duìshēng mìng生命quán lì权利zhì xù秩序delǐ jiě理解chā yì差异

Master, this reminds me of what you often say: 'Law is the mirror of culture.' How different countries perceive punishment also reflects their views on life, rights, and order.

陈智高
shuōhǎoruònéngjiè cǐ借此qì jī契机zhǎn kāi展开kuà wén huà跨文化duì huà对话huò xǔ或许dān chún单纯dekàng yì抗议gèngjiàn shè xìng建设性shì jiè世界suīfǎ lǜ法律dào yì道义quèyīng yǒu应有gòng tōng共通dedǐ xiàn底线

Well said. If this incident can prompt cross-cultural dialogue, it may be more constructive than mere protests. The world is vast, but laws and morality should share some common ground.

Why use the app

Access 1,000+ dialogues and all study tools

Ask the AI, use repeat playback, save vocabulary, and track your progress

Full archive

1,000+ dialogues and 500+ Easy Mandarin News articles are available.

Smarter practice

Use repeat playback, adjust audio speed, and save words to flashcards.

Ask the AI

Get instant explanations for grammar, usage, and sentence structure.