陈智高 and 王明月 discuss the cultural and legal differences behind the death penalty controversy between China and Canada.
Master, have you seen the recent news? China lawfully executed four Canadian drug traffickers. Canada strongly protested, but many foreign netizens supported China's actions, and even some Canadians expressed understanding.
Yes, I saw it. This actually reflects the cultural differences behind legal systems. Western countries generally oppose the death penalty, while China views drug crimes as a serious threat to social stability, so severe punishment is not surprising.
Right. I noticed one comment saying that Canadian media headlines should read 'Four Drug Traffickers' instead of 'Four Canadians.' That comment was spot-on.
This shows that the public is becoming more aware of the distinction between 'identity' and 'actions.' A country's law cannot be swayed by the criminal's nationality; otherwise, what remains of the rule of law? 'When in Rome, do as the Romans do' should also mean 'When in a country, abide by its laws.'
But Master, why is Canada still reacting so strongly? Is it due to humanitarian concerns or political considerations?
Both. Canada abolished the death penalty long ago, so from their value perspective, they find it hard to accept. Politically, if they don't protest, public opinion might criticize the government as 'doing nothing.' However, such protests could backfire and be seen as interference in another country's internal affairs.
I also saw a comment from an American netizen saying Canada once denied the drug traffickers were active in the US, but now the evidence is clear — a real slap in the face. It makes me think that public opinion sometimes has sharper insights than official statements.
The public eye is indeed keen. As the Chinese saying goes, 'The law does not bend to the powerful.' Regardless of status or nationality, those who break the law should be punished accordingly. In today's globalized world, countries should respect each other's judicial sovereignty in dealing with transnational crimes.
Master, this reminds me of what you often say: 'Law is the mirror of culture.' How different countries perceive punishment also reflects their views on life, rights, and order.
Well said. If this incident can prompt cross-cultural dialogue, it may be more constructive than mere protests. The world is vast, but laws and morality should share some common ground.
Why use the app
Ask the AI, use repeat playback, save vocabulary, and track your progress
1,000+ dialogues and 500+ Easy Mandarin News articles are available.
Use repeat playback, adjust audio speed, and save words to flashcards.
Get instant explanations for grammar, usage, and sentence structure.