yòng
用
AI
xiě
写
zuò yè
作业
:
zuò yè
作业
quán
全
duì
对
,
kǎo shì
考试
biàn
变
chà
差
Using AI for Homework: Perfect Assignments, Worse Exam Scores
yī xiàng一项zhuī zōng追踪liǎng wàn duō两万多míng名zhōng xué shēng中学生de的yán jiū研究fā xiàn发现,yòng用AIzhí jiē直接chāo抄dá àn答案huì会ràng让xué shēng学生zuò yè作业fēn shù分数tí gāo提高,dàn但kǎo shì考试chéng jì成绩míng xiǎn明显xià jiàng下降。

A study tracking more than 20,000 middle school students found that directly copying answers from AI improved homework scores but led to a significant decline in exam performance.

陈花
wǒ我kuài快bèi被wǒ men我们bān班xué shēng学生qì sǐ气死le了。zhè这xué qī学期zuò yè作业jiāo交shàng lái上来jī hū几乎quán全duì对,jié guǒ结果yuè kǎo月考píng jūn fēn平均分fǎn ér反而diào掉le了yī dà jié一大截。

My students are driving me crazy. Almost all the homework they turned in this semester was correct, but their average score on the monthly exam actually dropped a lot.

刘娜
gāi该bú huì不会shì是yòng用AIxiě写de的ba吧?wǒ我gāng刚kàn dào看到yī piān一篇bào dào报道,shuō说xiāng gǎng dà xué香港大学de的jiào shòu教授zhuī zōng追踪le了liǎng wàn两万duō多míng名zhōng xué shēng中学生,fā xiàn发现de的zhèng shì正是zhè zhǒng这种qíng kuàng情况。

Could they be using AI to do it? I just read a report about professors at the University of Hong Kong who tracked more than 20,000 middle school students and found exactly this kind of situation.

陈花
zhēn de真的jiǎ de假的?yán jiū研究jù tǐ具体shì是zěn me怎么shuō说de的?

Really? What exactly did the study say?

刘娜
zhí jiē直接ràng让AIgěi给dá àn答案de的xué shēng学生,zuò yè作业chéng jì成绩tí gāo提高le了18%,kě可bàn nián半年zhī nèi之内yuè kǎo月考chéng jì成绩píng jūn平均xià jiàng下降le了20%,liǎng nián两年hòu后zhōng kǎo中考chéng jì成绩zuì duō最多xià jiàng下降24%。

Students who asked AI to give them answers directly saw their homework scores rise by 18%, but within six months, their monthly exam scores fell by an average of 20%, and two years later, their high school entrance exam scores were down by as much as 24%.

陈花
zhè me这么yán zhòng严重!wǒ我hái还yǐ wéi以为tā men他们zhōng yú终于kāi qiào开窍le了ne呢。kě可xiàn zài现在jī hū几乎rén rén人人dōu都zài在yòng用,zǒng总bù néng不能wán quán完全bù不ràng让yòng用ba吧?

That's serious! I thought they'd finally gotten the hang of things. But almost everyone uses AI now, so we can't completely ban it, can we?

刘娜
yán jiū研究lǐ里shuō说,rú guǒ如果zhǐ shì只是ràng让AIjiǎng jiǎng讲讲sī lù思路,zì jǐ自己hái shì还是rèn zhēn认真huā shí jiān花时间zuò tí做题,jī běn基本méi shén me没什么yǐng xiǎng影响。wèn tí问题chū出zài在zhí jiē直接fù zhì复制zhān tiē粘贴dá àn答案。ér qiě而且chéng jì成绩yuè越hǎo好de的xué shēng学生,shòu dào受到de的yǐng xiǎng影响yuè越dà大。

The study said that if students only asked AI to explain how to solve a problem and still spent time working through it carefully themselves, there was basically no impact. The problem was directly copying and pasting answers. And the better a student's grades were, the greater the impact.

陈花
nán guài难怪wǒ men我们bān班nà那jǐ gè几个jiān zi shēng尖子生zuì jìn最近dà tí大题lǎo老diū fēn丢分!tā men他们jiā zhǎng家长gū jì估计yě也bù不zhī dào知道hái zi孩子zài在yòng用AI。

No wonder those top students in our class have been losing points on the big problems lately! Their parents probably don't even know they're using AI.

刘娜
hěn很yǒu有kě néng可能。bào dào报道lǐ里shuō说,yí bàn一半de的jiā zhǎng家长lián连hái zi孩子yòng用de的shì是shén me什么AIdōu都bù不qīng chǔ清楚。guāng光kào靠hái zi孩子zì jué自觉,kěn dìng肯定bù xíng不行。

That's very possible. The report said half of parents didn't even know which AI their children were using. We definitely can't rely on the kids' self-discipline alone.

陈花
kàn lái看来wǒ我míng tiān明天děi得kāi开gè个bān huì班会,zài再gēn跟jiā zhǎng家长men们hǎo hǎo好好gōu tōng沟通yī xià一下。guāng光jìn zhǐ禁止méi yòng没用,děi得ràng让hái zi孩子zì jǐ自己míng bái明白chāo抄dá àn答案dào dǐ到底chī吃le了duō dà多大de的kuī亏。

Looks like I'll have to hold a class meeting tomorrow and have a serious talk with the parents too. Simply banning AI won't work. We need to help the kids understand for themselves how much they lose by copying answers.

Why use the app

Access 1,000+ dialogues and all study tools

Ask the AI, use repeat playback, save vocabulary, and track your progress

Full archive

1,000+ dialogues and 500+ Easy Mandarin News articles are available.

Smarter practice

Use repeat playback, adjust audio speed, and save words to flashcards.

Ask the AI

Get instant explanations for grammar, usage, and sentence structure.