AI
néng
tì dài
替代
yī shēng
医生
ma
Can AI Replace Doctors?
chén zhì gāo陈智高wáng míng yuè王明月tàn tǎo探讨AIyī liáo医疗defā zhǎn发展jí qí及其jú xiàn局限

陈智高 and 王明月 discuss the development and limitations of AI in healthcare.

王明月
shī fù师父zuì jìn最近yǒuxīn wén新闻hěnyǒu yì sī有意思yī xiē一些bìng rén病人yòngAIgōng jù工具DeepSeekchábìngjié guǒ结果fā xiàn发现dezhěn duàn诊断shèn zhì甚至yī shēng医生gèngjīng zhǔn精准zhèràngyī shēng医生menhěnjiāo lǜ焦虑

Master, there's an interesting piece of news recently. Some patients have used the AI tool DeepSeek to diagnose illnesses, and it turns out its diagnoses are even more accurate than those of doctors. This has made some doctors quite anxious.

陈智高
zhèquè shí确实shìzhí de值得shēn sī深思dexiàn xiàng现象AIzàiyī xué医学lǐng yù领域deyìng yòng应用yuè lái yuè越来越guǎng fàn广泛néng gòu能够kuài sù快速fēn xī分析hǎi liàng海量shù jù数据bìngtí gōng提供hé lǐ合理dezhěn liáo诊疗jiàn yì建议dànzhèyì wèi zhe意味着yī shēng医生zhēn de真的huìbèiqǔ dài取代ma

This is indeed a thought-provoking phenomenon. AI is being increasingly applied in the medical field. It can quickly analyze vast amounts of data and provide reasonable treatment suggestions, but does that really mean doctors will be replaced?

王明月
cóngmù qián目前láikànDeepSeekgěichūdefāng àn方案hěnduōshí hòu时候shìzhèng què正确dedànyī shēng医生réng rán仍然shìzuì hòu最后dejué cè zhě决策者bì jìng毕竟AIzàicōng míng聪明wú fǎ无法zhēn zhèng真正lǐ jiě理解bìng rén病人

For now, DeepSeek often provides correct treatment plans, but doctors are still the final decision-makers. After all, no matter how intelligent AI is, it cannot truly 'understand' patients.

陈智高
méi cuò没错yī shēng医生bù jǐn jǐn不仅仅shìgēn jù根据shù jù数据láizhěn duàn诊断háixū yào需要jié hé结合bìng rén病人debìng shǐ病史shēng huó生活xí guàn习惯qíng xù zhuàng tài情绪状态děngyīn sù因素zhèshìAInán yǐ难以wán quán完全zhǎng wò掌握degènghé kuàng何况yī liáo医疗bù jǐn jǐn不仅仅shìkē xué科学shìrénrénzhī jiān之间dexìn rèn信任guān xì关系

Exactly. Doctors don't just diagnose based on data; they also consider the patient's medical history, lifestyle, emotional state, and other factors. These are aspects that AI finds difficult to fully grasp. Moreover, medicine is not just a science—it is also built on trust between people.

王明月
dànAIquè shí确实néngtí shēng提升yī liáo医疗xiào lǜ效率bǐ rú比如fǔ zhù辅助yī shēng医生jiě dú解读yǐng xiàng影像yōu huà优化zhěn liáo诊疗fāng àn方案shèn zhì甚至jiǎn shǎo减少wù zhěn误诊rú guǒ如果yùn yòng运用dé dàng得当huìchéng wéi成为yī shēng医生dedé lì得力zhù shǒu助手

But AI can indeed improve medical efficiency, such as assisting doctors in interpreting images, optimizing treatment plans, and even reducing misdiagnoses. If used properly, it can become a valuable assistant to doctors.

陈智高
zhèng shì正是rú cǐ如此rén gōng zhì néng人工智能shìgōng jù工具érbú shì不是tì dài替代zhějiùxiànggǔ dài古代dehuáng dì nèi jīng黄帝内经suǒshuōshàng yī zhì wèi bìng上医治未病zhēn zhèng真正gāo míng高明deyī shēng医生bù jǐn不仅zhì bìng治病gèngyàoguān zhù关注réndezhěng tǐ整体jiàn kāng健康érzhèkǒng pà恐怕bú shì不是AIsuǒnéngzuò dào做到de

That's right. Artificial intelligence is a tool, not a replacement. As the ancient text 《黄帝内经》 says, 'A great doctor treats illness before it occurs.' A truly skilled doctor not only treats diseases but also focuses on overall human health. And that is something AI is unlikely to achieve.

王明月
jiù shì shuō就是说AIkě yǐ可以fǔ zhù辅助yī shēng医生dànduǎn shí jiān短时间nèiwú fǎ无法wán quán完全qǔ dài取代yī shēng医生dejué sè角色

So, AI can assist doctors, but it cannot completely replace them in the near future?

陈智高
zhèng shì正是rú cǐ如此AIdejìn bù进步bù kě不可hū shì忽视dànyī xué医学dehé xīn核心shǐ zhōng始终shìrényī shēng医生dejīng yàn经验pàn duàn判断rén wén人文guān huái关怀cáishìyī liáo医疗zhēn zhèng真正delíng hún灵魂

Exactly. The progress of AI cannot be ignored, but the core of medicine is always 'people.' A doctor's experience, judgment, and humanistic care are the true essence of healthcare.

Why use the app

Access 1,000+ dialogues and all study tools

Ask the AI, use repeat playback, save vocabulary, and track your progress

Full archive

1,000+ dialogues and 500+ Easy Mandarin News articles are available.

Smarter practice

Use repeat playback, adjust audio speed, and save words to flashcards.

Ask the AI

Get instant explanations for grammar, usage, and sentence structure.